The Weimar Moment

Why America’s Inflation Echoes Germany’s Collapse of 1923

In the winter of 1923, an unsettling ritual unfolded daily in the cafés of Berlin. A customer would order a cup of coffee at one price, only to discover moments later that the cost had risen dramatically. Patrons began paying before their meals arrived, fearful that the bill would double between ordering and eating. This was not the result of profiteering or greed, but a desperate attempt by businesses to keep pace with a currency that was disintegrating in real time.

These scenes have since become iconic: wheelbarrows filled with banknotes, children stacking money like toys, households burning cash because it was cheaper than buying fuel. For decades, these images have been treated as historical curiosities—symbols of a uniquely German catastrophe born from defeat in war, punitive reparations, and political incompetence. The prevailing assumption has been that such madness could never recur in a modern, advanced economy.

Yet when the emotional distance of time is stripped away and the mechanics of the collapse are examined closely, the parallels between Weimar Germany and the United States in the 2020s are deeply unsettling. The hyperinflation that destroyed the German mark was not the result of fate or misfortune. It was the predictable outcome of deliberate policy choices. Those choices, disturbingly, bear a strong resemblance to those made by American policymakers in recent years.

The United States has not reached the terminal stage of currency collapse. The dollar remains widely accepted, and daily commerce continues. However, the conditions that precede monetary breakdown—the period of denial, rationalisation, and false confidence—are increasingly visible. To understand the risks ahead, it is necessary to revisit the past, not as distant tragedy, but as a cautionary case study.

Germany After the First World War: A Fragile Giant

In the early 1920s, Germany was a nation deeply wounded by war. Defeat in the First World War had brought not only territorial losses and political upheaval, but also crushing financial obligations under the Treaty of Versailles. Germany was required to make reparations payments to the Allied powers, many of them denominated in gold or foreign currency rather than paper marks. This distinction was crucial. While a government can print its own currency, it cannot print gold or dollars.

The reparations burden strained Germany’s finances, but it did not by itself doom the currency. Hyperinflation was not inevitable. The decisive turning point came with a political and economic crisis that transformed fiscal weakness into monetary catastrophe.

In January 1923, French and Belgian troops occupied the Ruhr Valley, Germany’s industrial heartland, after Germany defaulted on deliveries of coal and timber. The Ruhr was the engine of the German economy, producing the majority of its coal, steel, and heavy industrial output. Its occupation was an economic shock of the highest order.

Unable to respond militarily, the German government adopted a policy of “passive resistance”. Workers in the Ruhr were instructed not to cooperate with occupying forces. They were told to strike, stay home, and refuse production. This decision crippled Germany’s industrial output almost overnight.

However, the workers still needed to survive. To maintain social stability and political support, the government promised to pay their wages in full despite the halt in production. This commitment marked the beginning of the end for the German mark.

The Hyperinflation Equation: Supply Collapse Meets Monetary Explosion

The policy of passive resistance created a lethal economic equation. On one side, production collapsed. Coal, steel, and manufactured goods ceased to flow. The supply of real goods shrank dramatically. On the other side, government spending surged. Millions of workers were paid to produce nothing, and the state financed this expenditure by printing money.

This combination—severe supply contraction alongside explosive monetary expansion—is the classic trigger for hyperinflation. Prices did not merely rise; they accelerated uncontrollably. With fewer goods available and vastly more money in circulation, the value of each mark declined at an ever-increasing pace.

This dynamic is not confined to the past. In 2020, the United States responded to the global pandemic with strikingly similar logic. Economic activity was deliberately halted. Factories closed, supply chains fractured, ports slowed, and services shut down. The supply of goods and services contracted sharply.

At the same time, the government unleashed unprecedented fiscal stimulus. Trillions of dollars were distributed to households and businesses to sustain incomes during lockdowns. The Federal Reserve expanded its balance sheet at historic speed, purchasing government debt to fund these programmes.

The result was an artificial environment in which consumption was subsidised while production was constrained. For a time, the effects appeared benign. Savings increased, asset prices surged, and economic pain seemed muted. Yet this apparent stability masked a growing imbalance that would only become visible later.

The Illusion of Control and the Lag of Inflation

One of the most dangerous aspects of inflation is its delayed effect. There is often a significant gap between monetary expansion and visible price increases. During this interval, policymakers and the public may conclude that warnings were exaggerated and that conventional economic rules no longer apply.

Weimar Germany experienced such a phase in 1921 and 1922. A weaker currency boosted exports, employment appeared to recover, and business profits rose in nominal terms. For a brief period, inflation felt manageable. This illusion encouraged further monetary expansion.

The United States experienced a similar moment following pandemic stimulus. Asset markets boomed. Stock indices reached record highs. Housing prices soared. Consumer spending rebounded strongly. The sense prevailed that extraordinary policy measures had succeeded without serious cost.

But inflation, like gravity, cannot be defied indefinitely. Once price increases become embedded in expectations, the adjustment is sudden and severe. In Germany, the moment of reckoning arrived in 1923, when confidence in the mark evaporated almost overnight.

The Central Banker’s Trap: Rudolf Havenstein and Monetary Delusion

The collapse of the German currency is inseparable from the actions of the Reichsbank and its president, Rudolf Havenstein. Havenstein was not a reckless populist or a corrupt demagogue. He was a respected technocrat who believed he was acting in the best interests of the economy.

As prices rose, businesses complained of a shortage of money. They argued that they needed more liquidity to pay workers and purchase raw materials at higher prices. Havenstein accepted this logic. He viewed inflation as a consequence of economic disruption rather than monetary policy.

Each increase in prices prompted further demands for money, and each expansion of the money supply drove prices higher still. This feedback loop became self-reinforcing. Havenstein insisted that inflation was caused by external forces: foreign occupation, speculation, hoarding, and currency depreciation driven by hostile powers.

This mindset—blaming symptoms rather than causes—is a recurring feature of inflationary episodes. Modern central bankers have employed similar narratives, attributing price rises to supply chain disruptions, geopolitical conflict, corporate behaviour, or temporary shocks. Rarely is the expansion of the money supply acknowledged as the primary driver.

Monetising Private Debt: The Engine of Speculation

One of the less discussed but most destructive mechanisms of Weimar inflation was the monetisation of private debt. German companies routinely issued short-term bills to one another, which the Reichsbank accepted as collateral in exchange for newly printed money at minimal interest.

This effectively allowed private firms to convert debt into cash with state backing. Speculative ventures, acquisitions, and financial gambles were financed not through savings or profits, but through money creation. The incentive to borrow became overwhelming.

When inflation vastly exceeds interest rates, borrowing is rational. Loans are repaid with depreciated currency, while real assets retain value. This environment fuels what economists later termed a “crack-up boom”—a frenzy of speculation driven by the destruction of money itself.

Modern parallels are evident. Prolonged periods of ultra-low interest rates, combined with central bank asset purchases, have encouraged unprecedented levels of borrowing. Financial institutions and investors with access to cheap credit have accumulated vast portfolios of real assets, while savers have seen their purchasing power eroded.

Redistribution by Inflation: Winners, Losers, and the Death of the Middle Class

Inflation is not neutral. It redistributes wealth. Debtors benefit at the expense of creditors. Asset holders gain, while wage earners and savers lose. In Weimar Germany, this redistribution was extreme.

A new class of industrial magnates emerged, exploiting negative real interest rates to acquire factories, mines, newspapers, and infrastructure. By borrowing aggressively and purchasing tangible assets, they insulated themselves from monetary collapse and accumulated immense wealth.

Meanwhile, the middle class was annihilated. Civil servants, professionals, pensioners, and small savers—those who had trusted the state and saved diligently—were wiped out. Government bonds and savings accounts became worthless. Life-long security vanished in months.

This destruction of the middle class was not merely economic. It was moral and political. The middle class forms the backbone of social stability, democracy, and institutional trust. When its savings are erased, its loyalty to the system collapses.

Behavioural Collapse: From Thrift to Frenzy

As confidence in the currency evaporated, behaviour changed radically. Saving became irrational. Holding cash was suicidal. People rushed to exchange money for anything tangible: furniture, art, coal, foreign currency, or land.

Spending became frantic and indiscriminate. Goods were purchased not for use, but as stores of value. This phenomenon—now described as “flight into real values”—drove the velocity of money to extreme levels, accelerating inflation further.

Modern societies exhibit similar patterns in milder form. Younger generations increasingly spend on experiences, luxury goods, and travel despite limited financial security. This behaviour is often criticised as irresponsible, but in an environment of persistent inflation and unaffordable housing, it is a rational response to perceived futility.

Speculation as National Pastime

During the final phase of Weimar inflation, the stock market became a national obsession. Nominal prices soared to astronomical levels, creating the illusion of immense wealth. Yet in real terms, measured against gold or foreign currency, equity values collapsed.

The market ceased to function as a mechanism for allocating capital. It became a vehicle for absorbing excess liquidity. Speculation replaced investment. This distortion mirrors episodes in modern financial history, where asset bubbles inflate not due to fundamentals, but because money has nowhere else to go.

Moral Disintegration and Social Decay

The consequences of hyperinflation extended far beyond economics. As work lost its meaning and honesty ceased to pay, social norms deteriorated. Crime, corruption, and black markets flourished. Survival, not integrity, became the guiding principle.

Cities became sites of extreme inequality. Decadence and destitution coexisted. While some indulged in excess, others starved. The shared moral framework that binds a society dissolved along with its currency.

Collapse and Reset: The Rentenmark

By late 1923, the German economy had reached its breaking point. Barter replaced money. Farmers refused paper payments. Municipalities printed emergency currencies. The division of labour collapsed.

Stability returned only with the introduction of a new currency, the Rentenmark. Backed symbolically by land rather than gold, its success lay not in material backing, but in discipline. The supply was strictly limited. The government was forced to balance its budget.

Inflation stopped almost immediately. Yet the damage was irreversible. Wealth had been redistributed permanently. Debts erased. Savings destroyed.

The Lasting Lesson

The Weimar experience demonstrates that inflation is not merely a rise in prices. It is a systemic failure that reshapes society, politics, and morality. It rewards leverage and punishes prudence. It undermines trust and empowers extremism.

Modern economies are larger and more complex, but they are not immune. Excessive debt, monetary expansion, and the belief that prosperity can be printed carry consequences that no society can escape indefinitely.

The lesson is not that collapse is inevitable, but that denial is dangerous. Economic laws cannot be suspended forever. When confidence in money falters, the consequences extend far beyond balance sheets.

The question is not whether history repeats itself exactly, but whether its patterns are recognised before the damage becomes irreversible.

FAQs