The Government’s Migrant Crime Data Controversy
Why Is Britain Being Denied the Full Picture?
The Ministry of Justice is fighting an order to release detailed statistics on crimes committed by foreign nationals, while more than 21,000 foreign offenders remain in the community awaiting deportation. With public confidence in immigration enforcement under pressure, the Government faces growing questions about transparency, accountability and its willingness to disclose information in the public interest.
The debate surrounding immigration and crime in Britain has taken a significant turn following a dispute between the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) and the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) over the publication of detailed criminal conviction statistics.
At the centre of the controversy is a seemingly straightforward question: how many crimes are being committed by foreign nationals in Britain, what types of offences are involved, and which nationalities are represented in the figures?
Despite growing public interest in the subject, the Government has resisted releasing a comprehensive breakdown of convictions by nationality and offence category. An Information Commissioner’s ruling subsequently found that the Ministry’s arguments for withholding the information were insufficient, but rather than simply publish the figures, the department has appealed the decision.
The dispute has intensified an already contentious debate about immigration enforcement, public safety and whether the Government is being sufficiently transparent with the public.
The Ministry of Justice’s battle over conviction statistics
The controversy originated with a Freedom of Information request submitted in June 2025 by the Centre for Migration Control.
The organisation requested criminal conviction statistics covering the period 2018–2024, broken down by the nationality of offenders and the categories of offences committed.
The information sought included convictions for serious offences such as rape, sexual assault, murder, violent crime, robbery, drug offences, weapons offences and fraud.
The Ministry of Justice initially refused the request, citing the cost of extracting the information and concerns that publishing detailed breakdowns could potentially identify individuals.
However, the Information Commissioner’s Office subsequently challenged that position.
In a decision notice issued on 22 June 2026, reference IC-416928-D9J8, the ICO concluded that the Ministry had not adequately demonstrated that the cost exemption applied. It also found that privacy concerns did not justify withholding the entire dataset, although safeguards could legitimately apply to very small statistical groups where identification might be possible.
The distinction is important. The ICO was not demanding the publication of personal information or identifying individual offenders. It was requiring the release of statistical information that could be anonymised and presented in a way that protected privacy.
Rather than comply, the Ministry of Justice appealed to the First-tier Tribunal (General Regulatory Chamber).
A subsequent parliamentary answer on 27 July 2026 confirmed that the Government was challenging the ICO’s decision, arguing that disclosure while proceedings remained ongoing would prejudice the appeal.
Consequently, the public is still waiting for the comprehensive dataset.
This raises legitimate questions about why the Government is prepared to spend time and resources contesting the disclosure of information that an independent regulator has determined should largely be made available.
There is, of course, a legal process to follow, and an appeal does not in itself establish wrongdoing. Nevertheless, the decision to continue fighting disclosure does little to reassure those who believe the public deserves greater transparency.
The 2025 figures and questions over missing information
The controversy is not confined to the original request covering 2018–2024.
There have also been questions about the availability of comparable figures for 2025.
The Office for National Statistics confirmed in response to an information request that it did not hold crime statistics broken down by nationality or immigration status for that year, directing enquiries towards the Ministry of Justice.
This illustrates a wider problem with the way information about foreign-national offending is collected, managed and published.
The Home Office has introduced additional statistical reporting, including information about common nationalities, offence groups and sentence lengths. However, these releases do not necessarily provide the comprehensive conviction breakdown requested through the original Freedom of Information process.
It is therefore important to distinguish between the information that is available and the information that remains outstanding.
The issue is not necessarily that the Government possesses every conceivable statistic and is deliberately concealing it. Rather, there is a clear dispute over the disclosure of particular datasets, alongside gaps in the published information.
The public should be able to establish precisely what information is held, what is being published and what remains unavailable.
More than 21,000 foreign offenders remain in the community
Perhaps the most striking statistic in this debate comes directly from the Home Office.
In a parliamentary answer on 8 September 2026, the Government confirmed that 21,294 foreign national offenders were living in the community and subject to deportation at the end of June 2026.
This figure represents a substantial number of individuals who have come into contact with the criminal justice system and fall within the relevant deportation arrangements.
For comparison, the corresponding figure at the end of 2025 was 19,470.
That represents an increase of 1,824 individuals in just six months.
The Government attributed much of the increase to changes introduced under the Sentencing Act 2026, which expanded the circumstances in which foreign nationals receiving suspended sentences of 12 months or more became subject to deportation provisions.
However, there are important distinctions to understand.
These individuals should not automatically be described as people with final deportation orders who are simply waiting to be placed on an aircraft. The category includes foreign national offenders subject to deportation arrangements, and individual cases can be affected by legal challenges, human rights considerations, documentation difficulties and other practical barriers.
Nevertheless, the scale of the figure raises important questions.
Why are so many foreign national offenders still living in the community? How many are subject to completed deportation orders? How many have outstanding legal challenges? How many are being monitored, and how many have been successfully removed from the country?
These are reasonable questions that the Government should be able to answer.
Deportation policy is ultimately judged not by the number of people who are theoretically eligible for removal, but by whether the system actually delivers effective enforcement.
Public suspicion of a Government cover-up
The controversy is also reflected in public opinion.
Polling conducted by Find Out Now on 30 October 2026, involving 2,115 adults in Great Britain, found considerable support for greater transparency.
The research, commissioned by the Centre for Migration Control, reported that:
- 50% believed the Government was deliberately hiding information about crimes committed by foreign nationals.
- 54% supported publishing conviction statistics broken down by nationality.
- Only 14% opposed releasing the figures.
- 69% supported deporting all foreign nationals convicted of a criminal offence in Britain.
- Just 13% believed the Government was doing enough to tackle crime committed by foreign nationals.
The polling is particularly revealing because it highlights a wider crisis of public confidence.
It is important to recognise that the finding that half of respondents suspected a deliberate cover-up does not prove that one exists. The research was commissioned by an organisation campaigning for tighter immigration controls, and its findings should be considered in that context.
Nevertheless, the strength of support for publishing the information is difficult to ignore.
People do not necessarily need to agree on immigration policy to agree that the Government should publish reliable statistics about criminal offending.
Transparency is not an inherently anti-immigration position. It is a basic requirement of accountable government.
The importance of understanding what the figures actually show
While the demand for more detailed information is entirely reasonable, it is equally important that any statistics released are properly understood.
Research published by the University of Oxford’s Migration Observatory on 18 August 2026 provides useful context.
Its analysis found that non-UK citizens accounted for approximately 13.1% of people receiving cautions or convictions in 2024, while representing 12.1% of the prison population in June 2025.
The research also highlighted differences between offending categories and demographic groups.
Non-citizens appeared more likely to be represented in certain drug-related offences, while the available evidence suggested lower representation in some violent offence categories compared with British citizens.
The analysis also highlighted that non-citizens were disproportionately represented among prisoners held on remand awaiting trial.
Approximately 25% of non-citizens in prison had not yet been tried, compared with 11% of British citizens.
This is an important distinction because prison population figures cannot automatically be interpreted as figures for convicted offenders.
There are also other factors that must be considered when comparing offending rates.
Age, sex, socioeconomic circumstances and the length of time individuals have lived in Britain can all influence statistical comparisons. Nationality should not be confused with country of birth or immigration status, and British citizens with immigrant backgrounds are counted as British nationals.
The purpose of releasing detailed statistics should therefore be to allow meaningful analysis, rather than to produce simplistic comparisons or reinforce predetermined political arguments.
If particular nationalities are disproportionately represented in certain categories of offending, the public should be able to see that. Equally, if the evidence does not support particular claims, that should be made clear.
The only way to have an informed debate is to have access to the underlying information.
What about Greater Manchester and Andy Burnham?
The controversy has also generated allegations on social media concerning the availability of migrant crime statistics in Greater Manchester.
Some claims have suggested that Andy Burnham has withheld information relating to migrant crime during 2025.
However, this requires clarification.
Andy Burnham is no longer Mayor of Greater Manchester. Bev Craig took over the position on 3 August 2026.
Furthermore, responsibility for national criminal justice statistics rests principally with the Ministry of Justice and the Home Office, rather than the Greater Manchester Mayor.
The Mayor has significant responsibilities relating to policing and public accountability, but operational policing decisions remain with the Chief Constable.
There is currently insufficient independently verified evidence to establish that Burnham personally intervened to suppress Greater Manchester migrant crime statistics.
The wider question of whether Greater Manchester Police holds additional nationality-related data that has not been published remains legitimate and deserves investigation.
However, allegations should not be presented as established facts without supporting documentary evidence.
What should the Government publish?
The present situation highlights the need for a consistent, comprehensive and independently scrutinised system of reporting.
At a minimum, the Government should publish annual statistics covering:
- Nationality: The recorded nationality of individuals convicted of criminal offences.
- Offence categories: A breakdown covering violent crime, sexual offences, theft, robbery, drugs, fraud and other relevant categories.
- Convictions: Clear distinctions between arrests, charges, prosecutions and actual convictions.
- Sentencing: Information about custodial sentences, suspended sentences and sentence lengths.
- Demographics: Age and sex breakdowns to allow more meaningful comparisons.
- Immigration status: Where lawfully available, distinctions between visitors, settled residents, asylum seekers and other immigration categories.
- Deportation eligibility: The number of offenders who qualify for deportation under the relevant legislation.
- Enforcement: The number of individuals actually deported, alongside the number of outstanding cases and the reasons for delays.
The information should be published in a consistent format, allowing comparisons between years and enabling independent researchers to examine trends.
There should, of course, be appropriate privacy safeguards. Publishing statistics should never mean identifying individual offenders or exposing sensitive personal information.
However, protecting individual privacy should not become a blanket justification for withholding meaningful statistical information from the public.
It would also be sensible to publish comparable figures for British nationals, ensuring that any analysis is based on meaningful comparisons rather than raw numbers alone.
Transparency is not optional
The Government faces a difficult political environment surrounding immigration, crime and public confidence.
It is entirely reasonable for ministers to argue that immigration policy should be based on evidence rather than speculation. But that argument becomes considerably less convincing when the Government is simultaneously fighting the release of information that could help establish the facts.
The Ministry of Justice is entitled to pursue a legal appeal, and the outcome of that process should be respected. However, the public is equally entitled to question why disclosure is being resisted and whether the Government’s approach is consistent with its stated commitment to transparency.
More than 21,000 foreign national offenders subject to deportation arrangements remain in the community. The Government is contesting the release of detailed conviction statistics. Public confidence in immigration enforcement is clearly under pressure.
These are substantial issues that deserve more than political rhetoric.
The Government should publish the information wherever it can lawfully do so, explain any remaining restrictions and provide a clear timetable for resolving outstanding disclosure disputes.
Britain cannot have an informed debate about immigration and crime if the underlying evidence is incomplete or inaccessible.
The public is not asking for speculation, political spin or selective statistics. It is asking for the facts. And if the Government is confident that its immigration and criminal justice policies are working, it should have every reason to make those facts available.
